
The city of St. Augustine is proposing a garage sale ordinance, limiting the number of sales per year at four, with a maximum of three days per sale. City Commissioner Nancy Sikes-Kline was called by frustrated neighbors after they observed what they called a "large, multi-day sale". The commissioner visited the neighborhood, observing around thirty to fifty cars parked along the street, and then brought the matter to the city’s attention.
Mark Knight, city director of planning and building, drafted the ordinance at the request of the City Commission. A public hearing coming up March 26 will allow comments from the public and bring on a second vote.
"They had asked what we had on the books regulating garage sales, and we had to tell them that there wasn’t really anything specifically directed at them," Knight said. "So, they asked me to draw something up for them to look at. So, I went to Google to see what kinds of ordinances were out there in other cities."
Knight said he found a very simple ordinance "in Arkansas somewhere" that he thought would be a good starting point, then went to work customizing it to St. Augustine.
Many St. Augustine residents are rightfully upset with the proposed ordinance. Laura Forte, who had a garage sale last Saturday, said:
"To me, yard sales are like a fundamental right, part of American life," said Forte, who has owned her home for 13 years. "I’m not completely sure how I feel about this new ordinance the city is considering, but I don’t think it’s right."
Barbara Chapman, who was holding a sale in front of her apartment on Arricola Avenue on Anastasia Island, says:
"I don’t think it’s fair at all... I think as long as you’re not disturbing anybody, they should leave you alone. I should not have to register with the city to hold a sale in my own yard."
Assistant City Attorney Isabelle Lopez said she understands residents’ frustration with the proposed ordinance, but the city needed something on the books regarding garage sales, because there was nothing.
"You hate to have to regulate these things. And we want to hear what the public has to say about this. Our intent is [to] create a scenario where people would register, either online or in person, and we could track these things."
Personally, I see this as another excuse to put a tax on the people of St. Augustine. Six years ago, an ordinance was approved to ban artists and street performers from historic St. George Street without a proper permit. If you've ever been to St. Augustine, you know that the street performers are part of their culture and their local economy.
There seems to be a pattern across the country of increased government regulation assaulting private property rights. In Blytheville, AR. last year, residents were warned to remove their basketball goals off the edge of their lawn or face removal from the city. In Coralville, Iowa, 4-year-old Abigail Krutsinger had her lemonade stand shut down.
When will enough be enough?
(h/t The St. Augustine Record)










